For decades, the deaths of formerly enslaved people at the Devil’s Punchbowl were explained away as misfortune. The story suggested chaos after emancipation, people wandering into unsafe conditions, disease spreading naturally. No one was responsible. That framing isn’t neutral. It shifts blame onto the dead and turns mass death into an unfortunate accident rather than the result of policy.

The Confederacy was founded to preserve slavery. Secession documents stated it explicitly, speeches affirmed it, the Confederate constitution protected it, and leaders openly described slavery as the cornerstone of their government. These facts weren’t hidden or disputed at the time. What followed wasn’t confusion or forgetfulness, but deliberate replacement.